Although many in the audience laughed heartily at the moment, some were unsettled by the choices presented. Mbonyi’s choice sparked discussions about the boundaries of humor and the responsibilities of gospel artists when invited to comedy shows.

Some viewers expressed their discomfort on social media, posting clips of Israel Mbonyi choosing a condom over cannabis and alcohol, saying: “Gospel artists should take a cue from the Catholic Church and avoid being targeted by humor at Gen Z.”

Others questioned: “Why did Israel Mbonyi choose a condom at Gen Z Comedy? Who is responsible for gospel artists being publicly mocked?” Yet, one could argue the artists attended voluntarily, so responsibility is shared.

On the evening of October 30, 2025, at Camp Kigali, the special Gen Z Comedy Show blended humor with gospel music. Artists like Israel Mbonyi, along with Aline Gahongayire, Prosper Nkomezi, Jesca Mucyowera, and Alexis Dusabe, participated, marking a unique mix of comedy and worship music.

The show featured various comedians, including Pilate, Muhindee, Isacar, Rumi, MC Kandii, entertaining the audience with humorous performances.

One of the most talked-about moments was when Pilate asked Israel Mbonyi: “Here we have a cannabis wrap, a condom, and alcohol. If you had to choose one and we hold a gun to your head, what would you pick?” Mbonyi chose the condom. The act was immediately funny to many, but it also caused reflection on the nature of humor in such events.

Choosing a condom instead of alcohol or cannabis can be seen as a sign of prudence for someone who abstains from both substances for health, moral, and religious reasons.

• Alcohol can impair judgment, damage health, and cause relational conflicts. Mbonyi’s beliefs prohibit drinking, so choosing alcohol would contradict his values.

• Cannabis affects mental clarity, is illegal in Rwanda, and is considered harmful in the Bible. Choosing it would also contradict his values.

• A condom, however, represents a precautionary measure, preventing sexually transmitted diseases and unwanted pregnancies, without conflicting with personal or religious morals.
Some might argue that choosing a condom implies endorsing premarital sex. Yet for someone like Israel Mbonyi, it is a responsible choice, showing foresight and protection rather than moral compromise.

Although the exact reason for his choice wasn’t publicly explained, it reflects wisdom and foresight in someone aware of personal limitations.

However, this choice also raised concerns. Some believe gospel artists should avoid being made the butt of jokes. Participating in humor that targets religious values can affect the artist’s reputation and the perception of their faith.

Pilate, known for satirizing religion, had previously mocked the Catholic Church, leading to public criticism and an apology to Bishop Smaragde Mbonyintege. This history made some speculate that his question to Mbonyi might be part of a broader pattern of targeting religious figures.

The broader lesson is that gospel artists should exercise caution, ensuring humor does not compromise their values or mislead followers. They can use their wisdom and influence to guide the youth, emphasizing the importance of making thoughtful choices about participation in such events.

In the Gen Z Comedy show on October 30, 2025, artists including Aline Gahongayire, Prosper Nkomezi, Jesca Mucyowera, and Alexis Dusabe joined Israel Mbonyi in closing the show with gospel songs, demonstrating that worship and humor can coexist, but with careful boundaries.

Israel Mbonyi’s choice of a condom can be seen by some as a display of wisdom and prudence.
Do you personally see it that way?

Pilate’s question to Israel Mbonyi made some think he might be targeting religions or religious figures.

It was Israel Mbonyi’s first time invited as a special guest at these events.

Aline Gahongayire, Prosper Nkomezi, Jesca Mucyowera, and Alexis Dusabe participated with Israel Mbonyi in closing the show by performing gospel songs.